|
7. Balance, but don't mix.
The sixth feature,
using interesting stories to develop comprehension, should be balanced
with the decoding instruction described in the first five features. The
comprehension instruction and the decoding instruction should be separate
from each other while children are learning to decode, but both types
of instructional activities should occur. In other words, comprehension
and decoding instruction should be balanced.
The use of interesting authentic stories to develop language comprehension
is not ruled out by this research . . . using real stories to develop
comprehension should be balanced with decoding instruction . . . In
other words, comprehension and decoding instruction should be balanced.
|
A common misconception
regarding the balance that is called for by the research is that the teacher
should teach sound-spelling relationships in the context of real stories.
This mixture of decoding and comprehension instruction in the same instructional
activity is clearly less effective, even when the decoding instruction
is fairly structured. The inferiority of instructional activities with
mixed goals (embedded phonics) has been demonstrated in several studies.
During the early
stages of reading acquisition, children's oral language comprehension
level is much higher than their reading comprehension level. The text
material used to build children's comprehension should be geared to raise
their oral language comprehension level. The material used to build their
decoding should be geared to their decoding skills, with attention to
meaning. While decodable text can be meaningful and engaging, it will
not build children's comprehension skills nor teach them new vocabulary
to the extent that might be needed. Comprehension strategies and new vocabulary
should be taught using stories more sophisticated than the early decodable
text. The teacher should read this text to the children and discuss the
meaning with them. After the children become fluent decoders, the children
can apply these comprehension strategies to their own reading.
|